AZ ranks near bottom in grade school spending

In 2010, Virginia spent an average of $10,597 per public grade school student, like those shown here, compared to $7,848 spent per pupil in Arizona in the same year. (Photo courtesy Arlington, Va., Public Schools) 

By RYAN CLARK
Cronkite News Service

 

WASHINGTON – Arizona had the third-lowest per-pupil spending on public elementary schools in the country in 2010,topping only Utah and Idaho, according to a recent Census Bureau report.

Arizona schools spent an average of $7,848 per grade school student in that year, well below the national average of $10,615 per pupil, according to the Census report released in late June.

But Arizona school officials defended what they called efficient use of education dollars, noting that the state has posted some of the biggest gains on national standardized test scores despite the relatively low spending.

Since 2009, the state’s fourth-graders have posted the nation’s highest gains in the math section of the National Assessment of Educational Progress, said Molly Edwards, a spokeswoman for the Arizona Department of Education. She said Arizona schools have to determine how to deliver a quality education to students based on the funds available.

“We are always on the lookout for ways to bring in additional dollars, but we also have a responsibility not to give up just because we aren’t getting as much money as other states,” she said.

In addition to spending less per student, state funds also made up a smaller portion of total school spending in Arizona than in most other states, the report said. Nationally, state funding makes up 45 percent of school spending on average, with the rest coming from local and federal sources; in Arizona, state support makes up just 35 percent of the $8.8 billion that was spent on elementary education in 2010.

That’s just not enough, said David Garcia, a professor of education at Arizona State University.

“Education is a state responsibility, and each state, in its constitution, decides how they are going to fund education,” Garcia said.

The Arizona Constitution says the state will ensure and fund a “general and uniform” education for all students. But all that guarantees is that each school district gets the same amount of funding per pupil, Garcia said, not that students get a good education.

With 65 percent of school funding generally going to teacher salaries, schools in underfunded states can face a difficult choice between raising teacher salaries or reducing class sizes, said Mike Griffith, a finance analyst for the Education Commission of the States.

“In states that have higher funding, you often will see both smaller class sizes and higher pay,” Griffith said. “But if you walk into a class room in a lower-funded state, often you will see larger classes and lower-paid teachers – it’s an indirect correlation between spending and student achievement.”

But he cautioned that higher spending does not automatically result in schools that are getting the results they should.

“You can also find districts that don’t have as much money but have high achievement – it’s all about how they spend the money,” Griffith said.

Garcia said that the first step in solving the funding problem in Arizona is recognizing that there is a problem.

“And for anyone in education, Arizona being one of the lowest-funded states, isn’t going to be news,” he said.

DO THE MATH

States and the amount the spent in 2010 on public elementary school education, per pupil, ranked from lowest to highest spending.

1. Utah $6,064

2. Idaho $7,106

3. Arizona $7,848

4. Oklahoma $7,896

5. Tennessee $8,065

6. Mississippi $8,119

7. North Carolina $8,409

8. Nevada $8,483

9. Florida $8,741

10. Texas $8,746

11. Colorado $8,853

12. South Dakota $8,858

13. Alabama $8,881

14. Kentucky $8,948

15. South Carolina $9,143

15. Arkansas $9,143

17. California $9,375

18. New Mexico $9,384

19. Georgia $9,394

20. Washington $9,452

21. Indiana $9,611

22. Oregon $9,624

23. Missouri $9,634

24. Kansas $9,715

25. Iowa $9,763

26. Montana $10,497

27. Virginia $10,597

National average $10,615

28. Louisiana $10,638

29. Michigan $10,644

30. Minnesota $10,685

31. Nebraska $10,734

32. North Dakota $10,991

33. Ohio $11,030

34. Wisconsin $11,364

35. West Virginia $11,527

36. Illinois $11,634

37. Hawaii $11,754

38. Maine $12,259

39. Delaware $12,383

39. New Hampshire $12,383

41. Pennsylvania $12,995

42. Rhode Island $13,699

43. Maryland $13,738

44. Massachusetts $14,350

45. Connecticut $14,906

46. Wyoming $15,169

47. Vermont $15,274

48. Alaska $15,783

49. New Jersey $16,841

50. New York $18,618

51. District of Columbia $18,667